FS regulatory affairs newsletter – Q2 2023
In continuation of our previous FS regulatory affairs newsletter, this edition highlights the key regulatory updates from the second quarter of 2023.
Consumer Duty – Q2 2023
Consumer Duty: Findings from the FCA’s review of fair value frameworksThe FCA has sought to understand how firms across the sectors are implementing the price and value requirements ahead of the introduction of the Consumer Duty. Released in May 2023, the publication does not introduce new rules, rather it focuses on the existing requirement that the price a customer pays for a product or service is reasonable compared to the overall benefits. The FCA stated that firms can consider additional factors to use in their value assessments, but the following are the core considerations:
In demonstrating that the product price is reasonable, the FCA suggested firms might consider:
| ||
What management should consider Firms should ensure that their fair value assessments incorporate the core considerations stipulated by the FCA. For example, have you identified the benefits of a product that could be reasonably expected by a retail customer? Do you and the customer have clarity over product limitations, for example on scope of insurance cover? Have you anticipated the total price a customer could pay for a product and service? Are you still assured that this final cost demonstrates good value for a consumer? Have you distinguished between costs to you of new products, and accrued costs of existing products? | ||
The FCA acknowledged that firms are making substantial efforts in implementing the Duty. However, they also commented that, since the price and value rules are not prescriptive, firms have adopted a wide range of approaches in their value assessments, with some assessments prompting questions as to their effectiveness. Key findings from the FCA’s review are captured below. 1. Understanding of the fair value rules
| ||
What management should consider Management should ensure there is clear understanding and definition of what fair value is and the requirements of the fair value outcome. Definitions should be informed by the regulator’s comments and communicated throughout a firm. Consensus over the ‘fair value’ definition will assist in performing fair value assessments and developing a consistent approach. For example, where there is perception that a business model is inherently fair, or that products are by nature valuable, what evidence is available to support this? How do you perform your own analysis to ensure you are providing fair value for each product? | ||
2. Assessing value
| ||
What management should consider Firms should consider all fees and charges within their fair value assessments. This should include non-monetary costs, such as the effort required to amend a product, and potential distribution costs to consumers. Prices of packaged products should match the sum of the individually priced components, and if not, is there a clear rationale for this? If products are purchased through different channels, can any price variation be justified? | ||
3. Considering contextual factors
| ||
What management should consider Firms should ensure that the fair value assessments consider factors beyond the financial value of the product. This may include consideration of sludge and nudge practices, whether customers hold other products with the firm and customer behavioural biases. | ||
4. Assessing differential outcomes
| ||
What management should consider The FCA does not require firms to charge all customers the same amount, nor to make the same level of profit from all customers. However, management should ensure that they have assessed the value of differential outcomes for consumers. This might include the value received by back-book customers, consumers using different channels and other subsets of consumers. | ||
5. Data and governance
| ||
What management should consider Management should specify timelines or triggers for conducting value assessments. This might correspond to an expected length of time a consumer would utilise a product. Management should also have identified the data needed to monitor fair value as well as any data required to address gaps. It is important for firms to assess whether their measurement approaches, such as RAG ratings, provide sufficient detail or link to thresholds to be of value. | ||
Consumer Duty: Findings from the FCA’s firm surveyTo mark the approach of the deadline, the FCA recently published the results of a survey looking at the preparedness of firms to meet the deadline. This survey was undertaken between March and May 2023 and looked at a sample of c.1200 mainly SME firms. The survey revealed that 23% of firms said they would still have some work to do after the deadline. A further 7% of firms said they would still have significant work to go or had not yet started work. Many firms are facing challenges with reaching full compliance with the Duty in time. We set out the key areas of interest and findings from the survey below. Knowledge gaps Retail finance providers and debt advice firms scored the lowest in terms of their engagement, understanding of the Duty and implementation progress against other firms. When asked whether the portfolios agreed or strongly agreed that the Consumer Duty was a high priority within their organisation, 59% of retail finance providers and 56% of debt advice firms responded that this was the case. This contrasted with 87% of all firms across portfolios who agreed the Consumer Duty was a high priority in their organisation. | ||
What management should consider Management should be mindful that from 31 July 2023, boards, senior management and all staff should have a thorough understanding of what is expected from them in their role under the Duty. Firm-wide campaigns, town hall presentations and targeted workshop training sessions will all facilitate a better understanding of the Duty. | ||
Outcomes monitoringThe FCA asked survey respondents what further areas of the Duty they would like the FCA to provide more information about. Outcomes monitoring, including data and metrics, was chosen by 51% of respondents as the leading topic they would like further information on. At the end of June 2023, the FCA published a podcast specifically on outcomes monitoring. We highlight the key points from the podcast below, where Ed Smith, Head of FCA Competition Policy, was interviewed on outcomes monitoring. | ||
What management should consider Firms should include processes to identify the root cause of poor outcomes for customers. This means that firms must be able to monitor distinct groups of customers to see whether they might be receiving worse outcomes than others. While the type and source of data collected as part of the outcomes monitoring strategy will vary across firms, many existing sources of data will still be relevant to the approach taken under the Duty. The FCA highlighted the value of data related to cancellation rates and reasons, complaints, and customer feedback as useful sources to provide insight into customer treatment and outcomes. Management needs to be able to evidence that action is being taken to mitigate risks of harm and that the strategy to deliver good outcomes is working in practice. A starting point is to establish a log of interventions made to improve outcomes. This could include a wide range of actions such as changes to product design, amendments to communications, such as clarifying charges, or a change to the target market. Firms are responsible for outcomes monitoring and compliance with the wider Duty expectations even where they outsource key activities to third parties. As a result, management will need to make sure that there are arrangements with outsourcers to capture the data they need to demonstrate good outcomes across the customer journey. |
If you require support or would like to know more, please get in touch via the button below.
This website uses cookies.
Some of these cookies are necessary, while others help us analyse our traffic, serve advertising and deliver customised experiences for you.
For more information on the cookies we use, please refer to our Privacy Policy.
This website cannot function properly without these cookies.
Analytical cookies help us enhance our website by collecting information on its usage.
We use marketing cookies to increase the relevancy of our advertising campaigns.